Why do you think it's not actually from Cecil's bat? I don't see any reason why it wouldn't be, unless you're just convinced that the card companies are nothing but liars and cheats.
it's all about having faith i guess. i figured it's not from "any specific game or season", and with probably tens of thousands of bats (or more) in topps archives used for relics, who knows! liars and cheats! (*just kidding topps).*courtesy of the TC-TCFCOT(EO)D legal department.